ProDeo
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
ProDeo

Computer Chess
 
HomeHome  CalendarCalendar  Latest imagesLatest images  FAQFAQ  SearchSearch  MemberlistMemberlist  UsergroupsUsergroups  RegisterRegister  Log in  

 

 Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.

Go down 
AuthorMessage
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptySun Oct 02, 2022 4:05 pm

I am using Centipawn Analysis by Chessbase to screen all games played in the year 2022 by GM Carlsen, GM Nakamura, GM So, GM Aronian, GM Firouzja, and GM Hans Niemann.

We will follow the Chessbase instructions. (instructions below)

And see what kind of cheating data we can produce as an experiment.

Current Raw Data of the 1386 games to be analyzed.

Karjakin Sergey:   7  => Average=0.07
Saric Ivan:   9  => Average=0.09
Predke Alexandr:   4/18  => Average=0.10
Grischuk Alexander:   16/21/9  => Average=0.15
Shirov Alexei:   27/9  => Average=0.21
Navara David:   22  => Average=0.22
Dominguez Perez Leinier:   43/4/62/7/0/1  => Average=0.23
Kovalenko Igor:   27/20  => Average=0.24
Grandelius Nils:   25  => Average=0.25
Volokitin Andrei:   25  => Average=0.25
Carlsen Magnus:   43/33/23/41/21/68/19/40/34/28/11/71/28/23/71/15/45/70/20/40/18/16/4/35/10/22/10/24/13/14/32/33/5/9/33/26/5/16/27/47/43/4/14/35/12/40/10/29/27/8/8/5/20/7/6/18/6/6/30/23/3/17  => Average=0.26
Caruana Fabiano:   17/38/58/10/16/57/51/10/8/3/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.26
Artemiev Vladislav:   57/6/42/21/16/9  => Average=0.28
Shankland Samuel L:   16/79/9/6  => Average=0.29
So Wesley:   13/37/93/39/28/52/25/51/31/51/20/86/66/20/21/27/19/10/19/5/12/11/6/12/27/27/7/33/15/55/22/8/45/82/9/3/13/18/34/43/6/4/2/40/1/5/8/18/12/0/0/1/0  => Average=0.29
Vidit Santosh Gujrathi:   22/60/11/9/52  => Average=0.30
Aronian Levon:   14/36/29/19/21/24/22/64/63/52/9/53/115/32/55/70/99/13/19/39/29/52/50/44/19/6/7/15/28/30/30/29/51/7/54/10/41/9/41/43/46/42/23/34/26/3/62/10/20/8/16/20/4/47/18/13/25/8/2/77/13/9/11/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.32
Giri Anish:   54/38/22/10/61/5/72/15  => Average=0.35
Mamedyarov Shakhriyar:   38/46/57/5  => Average=0.38
Ding Liren:   62/30/6/37/53/41/34/11  => Average=0.39
Oparin Grigoriy:   29/21/50/40/5/96/16/76  => Average=0.39
Anton Guijarro David:   48/67/77/14/13/8  => Average=0.41
Nakamura Hikaru:   107/122/96/56/52/51/48/49/23/25/8/61/54/44/19/63/18/22/32/18/80/31/45/55/19/19/16/31/27/70/49/40/84/21/46/21/41/25/17/69/5/6/52/44/38/62/68/8/39/26/50/54/90/17/2/23/8/31/25/14/72/48/21/49/20/31/12/51/50/45/16/31/22/67/37/6/10/39/36/40/11/20/9/35/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.41
Maghsoodloo Parham:   13/43/73/36/55  => Average=0.42
Le Quang Liem:   39/67/55/43/43/22/8/74/6/65  => Average=0.42
Keymer Vincent:   56/37/70/16/35/37/18/44/43/57/34/90/12  => Average=0.43
Guseinov Gadir:   46/0  => Average=0.43
Kamsky Gata:   54/5/68/43  => Average=0.43
Dubov Daniil:   48/61/27/26/119/55/34/28/7/12/54/0  => Average=0.44
Abdusattorov Nodirbek:   59/24/18/81/39/45/62  => Average=0.45
Nepomniachtchi Ian:   46/22/48/97/108/36/56/76/36/72/70/55/53/59/61/71/70/26/25/85/51/71/43/18/11/19/10/22/25/57/43/45/118/81/23/55/22/23/4/60/2/15/39/5/2/1/29/34/10/0/0  => Average=0.46
Jones Gawain C B:   31/31/51/87  => Average=0.46
Esipenko Andrey:   55/67/28/78/19/56/62/57/22/29/15/115/9/45  => Average=0.47
Duda Jan Krzysztof:   51/48/31/69/39/69/119/25/52/13/6/28/5/57  => Average=0.47
Deac Bogdan Daniel:   17/46/6/55/150  => Average=0.48
Svidler Peter:   49  => Average=0.49
Matlakov Maxim:   27/80/47/0/0  => Average=0.50
Andreikin Dmitry:   25/81/60/24  => Average=0.50
Rapport Richard:   100/46/38/14  => Average=0.52
Erigaisi Arjun Kumar:   45/65/49/57  => Average=0.53
Xiong Jeffery:   84/48/72/25/22/0  => Average=0.53
Tari Aryan:   57  => Average=0.57
Vachier Lagrave Maxime:   80/31/88/84/38/2  => Average=0.57
Harikrishna Pentala:   106/16/5  => Average=0.57
Sarana Alexey:   50/69/60/42/69/102/72/81/36/20/19/17  => Average=0.58
Fedoseev Vladimir1:   56/85/88/60/25/100/44/2  => Average=0.60
Van Foreest Jorden:   76/106/43/47/91/49/30  => Average=0.65
Demchenko Anton:   75/116/37/72/88/44/35  => Average=0.68
Sunilduth Lyna Narayanan:   50/118  => Average=0.77
Sjugirov Sanan:   101/46  => Average=0.81
Alekseenko Kirill:   111  => Average=1.11

My analysis screen shot of the current analysis, and the Chessbase Centipawn Analysis instructions below.

http://help.chessbase.com/CBase/16/Eng/index.html?centipawn_analysis.htm
Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Analys10

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Ca10
Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyMon Oct 03, 2022 9:37 pm

Nothing is standing out in the raw data so far. And the list is in Centipawn rank order. GM Hans Niemann games will be the last to be run. 893 games of 1386 games complete.

Ivanchuk Vassily:   6  => Average=0.06
Karjakin Sergey:   7  => Average=0.07
Shevchenko Kirill:   7  => Average=0.07
Predke Alexandr:   4/18  => Average=0.10
Navara David:   22/0  => Average=0.20
Shirov Alexei:   27/9  => Average=0.21
Radjabov Teimour:   16/18/27/2/30/20/19/26/16/84/4  => Average=0.22
Kovalenko Igor:   27/20  => Average=0.24
Volokitin Andrei:   25  => Average=0.25
Ding Liren:   62/26/3/68/30/6/37/5/27/53/41/17/23/18/18/2/1/4/34/11  => Average=0.27
Artemiev Vladislav:   57/6/42/21/16/9  => Average=0.28
Carlsen Magnus:   30/43/33/23/22/41/11/58/102/33/21/21/68/19/40/34/50/28/45/36/58/11/68/71/63/68/28/23/25/29/31/26/38/59/71/52/54/15/27/68/29/65/45/70/20/8/28/20/40/18/16/11/4/35/32/22/10/22/10/25/25/18/17/6/49/50/24/13/8/14/39/17/45/27/33/32/37/5/9/25/33/5/26/5/16/11/7/27/27/47/43/26/4/14/48/35/61/18/11/12/15/11/39/40/15/35/27/10/29/11/27/13/18/8/28/8/29/4/69/14/5/14/20/7/6/20/8/6/18/6/25/7/4/6/19/1/12/30/49/3/3/9/8/2/23/3/17  => Average=0.29
Caruana Fabiano:   17/54/36/16/89/38/32/27/51/4/36/20/37/19/58/59/60/35/44/14/10/6/16/57/28/16/15/10/19/51/10/12/6/8/14/5/3/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.29
Firouzja Alireza:   48/13/71/86/70/54/28/28/77/22/48/54/6/58/29/5/56/49/8/7/6/40/9/9/12/20/20/80/36/15/7/34/34/2/16/20/21/25/28/46/30/17/14/40/15/14/2/1/10/12/33/37/10/1/4/2  => Average=0.30
Wei Yi:   33/27/17/46/50/37/30/26/16  => Average=0.31
Topalov Veselin:   31/50/21/21/19/15/62/63/68/25/42/8/4/20  => Average=0.33
Dominguez Perez Leinier:   36/26/43/35/65/53/4/67/28/32/112/33/3/62/19/9/50/7/7/3/18/0/9/1  => Average=0.33
Vidit Santosh Gujrathi:   51/22/75/33/60/11/2/68/16/12/9/8/52/19  => Average=0.33
So Wesley:   92/39/58/74/13/50/46/94/96/34/75/37/42/39/33/82/93/41/20/46/39/16/33/32/28/23/124/16/52/8/33/25/44/28/29/27/16/51/46/31/57/51/18/56/57/20/8/6/86/66/28/20/31/46/21/27/8/19/35/16/76/10/15/58/12/19/73/5/15/87/23/9/10/36/64/87/49/24/41/36/8/21/12/60/2/23/11/100/89/42/6/12/11/8/8/22/18/12/5/27/27/21/12/19/43/13/7/17/14/33/1/19/15/34/12/14/31/22/55/3/22/5/2/22/36/83/10/7/15/22/8/37/45/82/9/5/3/7/13/18/34/43/44/71/0/27/30/18/21/20/22/6/53/9/5/14/4/2/0/8/26/5/14/12/20/40/1/12/5/3/8/1/6/3/18/7/10/26/21/5/12/1/0/0/0/0/2/18/13/0/0/0  => Average=0.33
Anton Guijarro David:   23/25/11/52/48/67/77/14/13/8  => Average=0.34
Aronian Levon:   29/40/31/14/114/68/41/36/29/36/43/13/21/19/21/44/53/62/24/22/56/64/63/52/39/92/82/83/85/51/9/47/25/53/53/115/32/26/38/55/45/70/28/43/19/20/99/13/36/42/28/11/78/19/14/62/39/61/33/32/52/26/29/51/19/38/27/42/5/30/29/30/52/53/30/50/9/37/31/17/44/55/21/9/39/17/48/19/6/7/60/15/30/28/36/44/47/65/30/29/9/51/35/33/36/46/7/28/54/47/10/27/41/9/19/41/42/43/17/34/20/4/46/15/42/23/34/14/28/26/16/15/52/33/57/84/10/18/3/1/3/62/12/26/43/9/10/22/20/8/55/11/16/35/6/20/4/47/18/12/30/13/25/20/15/14/6/34/18/8/2/77/24/13/9/25/23/11/9/43/15/8/4/9/6/6/0/17/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/16/10  => Average=0.35
Shankland Samuel L:   52/20/49/37/16/79/32/9/6  => Average=0.35
Mamedyarov Shakhriyar:   67/127/71/48/25/28/15/38/10/9/17/39/92/46/57/5/11/53/25/21/25/27/5/12/15/14/13/11/15/2/5  => Average=0.36
Grischuk Alexander:   42/49/60/16/84/48/36/9/27/28/66/72/1/13/22/21/30/14/9/0/0/0  => Average=0.36
Anand Viswanathan:   56/77/20/54/61/13/25/15/10/15/5/8  => Average=0.37
Nakamura Hikaru:   107/122/27/52/66/96/28/73/78/66/56/56/81/26/64/52/51/48/15/33/70/49/36/75/30/18/23/25/8/61/44/54/28/8/5/19/36/3/87/63/53/52/63/94/43/32/25/61/41/18/64/40/48/15/98/14/39/22/40/14/5/6/46/75/39/32/29/18/52/80/86/50/54/5/4/4/31/18/45/55/19/10/11/21/19/43/16/31/27/51/70/49/29/63/84/12/81/40/56/56/84/21/57/40/60/46/21/41/71/34/25/17/69/58/28/17/5/6/8/18/21/26/52/44/38/62/21/14/16/68/19/13/41/11/25/15/41/8/39/15/14/26/13/50/62/1/95/49/28/45/54/90/12/19/10/17/2/30/23/8/43/31/25/14/72/61/48/21/49/20/59/51/31/38/33/30/3/12/51/25/26/10/39/50/18/45/25/16/32/16/38/31/24/15/14/6/0/1/22/27/35/10/28/15/29/9/2/9/17/29/42/0/67/27/37/18/6/10/45/88/39/36/64/31/40/31/45/17/3/23/11/20/29/5/6/110/28/9/10/11/23/36/22/9/6/35/30/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.37
Abdusattorov Nodirbek:   71/59/24/8/18/53/38/22/81/76/43/39/21/38/14/27/15/45/62/40/5  => Average=0.39
Nepomniachtchi Ian:   46/22/48/60/67/14/97/108/36/11/21/14/45/63/15/19/90/94/79/8/32/13/56/76/36/80/72/38/29/70/44/55/22/44/53/52/59/14/61/23/53/71/49/70/26/25/14/85/80/70/61/51/71/43/18/9/20/18/11/57/60/5/19/19/11/7/44/10/22/16/25/12/15/73/57/43/21/45/118/81/23/32/55/22/35/55/67/7/18/23/31/27/4/60/20/17/2/15/4/39/36/24/14/5/8/5/1/2/13/29/10/0/0/34/10/8/16/11/1/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.39
Sevian Samuel:   28/85/94/64/17/15/29/68/14/11/8/10/21/16/18/0  => Average=0.39
Erigaisi Arjun Kumar:   47/22/32/45/15/65/22/63/49/57/0  => Average=0.39
Wang Hao:   46/84/34/5/46/4  => Average=0.40
Gledura Benjamin:   21/65  => Average=0.41
Wojtaszek Radoslaw:   44/92/45/35/18/6/7  => Average=0.41
Moussard Jules:   64/42/28/19  => Average=0.41
Keymer Vincent:   56/37/70/16/35/37/18/44/43/57/34/26/90/12/8  => Average=0.41
Giri Anish:   54/38/63/104/22/10/58/52/71/25/47/61/37/3/5/72/15/8/9/19/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.41
Le Quang Liem:   49/39/53/57/67/55/43/48/78/16/43/22/8/14/74/6/19/53/65/4  => Average=0.42
Xiong Jeffery:   53/50/48/84/89/114/14/48/26/44/54/45/18/7/56/72/25/29/58/22/33/12/5/11/13/48/0/0  => Average=0.44
Deac Bogdan Daniel:   28/17/46/90/75/6/18/55/37/150/9/5  => Average=0.44
Duda Jan Krzysztof:   51/49/91/66/46/48/31/69/30/24/42/80/41/39/14/69/119/70/22/25/52/9/27/10/8/13/6/28/5/84/57/4/74/22/6  => Average=0.44
Rapport Richard:   53/69/15/66/59/67/29/1/123/100/13/46/38/14/46/48/59/3/43/0/5/25/7  => Average=0.44
Andreikin Dmitry:   25/120/72/81/60/20/61/31/93/42/23/14/33/32/45/13/23/80/1/3/83/33/67/1/22/24/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.45
Dubov Daniil:   48/84/61/71/27/26/32/119/55/20/34/28/4/7/12/26/54/0/0  => Average=0.45
Saric Ivan:   70/75/16/104/21/15/74/16/13/9  => Average=0.46
Oparin Grigoriy:   87/71/27/29/21/50/40/23/5/96/16/76  => Average=0.46
Kamsky Gata:   54/47/5/68/56/43/60/33/42  => Average=0.46
Guseinov Gadir:   46/52/0  => Average=0.47
Robson Ray:   75/77/15/8/86/35/15  => Average=0.47
Esipenko Andrey:   55/30/67/28/78/19/56/62/88/57/22/29/42/15/51/115/29/9/45/12  => Average=0.47
Svidler Peter:   49  => Average=0.49
Vachier Lagrave Maxime:   35/96/101/50/124/9/80/68/31/88/38/37/10/18/26/52/68/84/10/15/14/38/23/2/42/3  => Average=0.49
Maghsoodloo Parham:   13/83/43/51/73/61/36/55/41/0  => Average=0.50
Van Foreest Jorden:   76/72/106/15/43/34/47/32/72/91/49/44/30/67/12/31/30/16/29/3  => Average=0.50
Harikrishna Pentala:   106/38/16/5  => Average=0.52
Fedoseev Vladimir1:   51/56/74/50/89/78/85/81/36/85/22/45/6/88/60/25/100/44/8/28/17/2/43/24/30/0/7/0/0/0  => Average=0.52
Grandelius Nils:   25/50/107  => Average=0.55
Jones Gawain C B:   62/84/31/31/51/87/21/68  => Average=0.55
Sunilduth Lyna Narayanan:   50/35/118/34/52/57  => Average=0.56
Salem AR Saleh:   46/68  => Average=0.56
Sarana Alexey:   50/69/36/94/40/60/86/42/69/65/102/61/76/52/72/26/60/81/36/82/20/19/13/22/17  => Average=0.58
Bluebaum Matthias:   71/50/61  => Average=0.60
Matlakov Maxim:   39/77/46/128/79/27/74/60/113/80/15/47/6/78/9/0/0  => Average=0.62
Demchenko Anton:   91/75/29/73/44/116/37/72/88/44/68/35/54  => Average=0.64
Korobov Anton:   85/11/70/98/58/86  => Average=0.64
Tari Aryan:   81/147/40/57/15/8/61/175/43/18/42/35  => Average=0.67
Melkumyan Hrant:   68  => Average=0.68
Sjugirov Sanan:   101/134/73/88/32/22/77/46/45/34  => Average=0.71
Swiercz Dariusz:   125/49/31  => Average=0.78
Alekseenko Kirill:   69/111/114/87  => Average=0.94
Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyMon Oct 03, 2022 9:43 pm

Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 12:05 am

All games have been run. And here is the Raw Data in performance rank order.

Shevchenko Kirill:   7  => Average=0.07
Karjakin Sergey:   7  => Average=0.07
Nihal Sarin:   8  => Average=0.08
Nyzhnyk Illya:   7/12  => Average=0.09
Predke Alexandr:   4/18  => Average=0.10
Tabatabaei Mohammad Amin:   14/0  => Average=0.12
Shirov Alexei:   27/9  => Average=0.21
Navara David:   22/1/56/19/7/0  => Average=0.21
Radjabov Teimour:   16/18/27/2/30/20/19/26/16/84/4  => Average=0.22
Kovalenko Igor:   27/20  => Average=0.24
Volokitin Andrei:   25  => Average=0.25
Martirosyan Haik M:   27  => Average=0.27
Ding Liren:   62/26/3/68/2/30/6/37/5/27/53/41/17/23/18/86/18/2/1/5/4/34/11  => Average=0.27
Artemiev Vladislav:   57/6/42/21/16/9  => Average=0.28
Vidit Santosh Gujrathi:   51/22/75/33/60/11/2/68/16/12/9/8/8/52/19  => Average=0.31
Caruana Fabiano:   17/47/54/36/59/16/89/38/37/32/27/51/25/4/2/55/36/77/20/40/37/19/58/119/4/59/60/35/44/31/14/18/10/80/6/19/1/83/10/16/17/16/57/28/28/43/32/18/16/15/10/2/19/51/10/12/6/8/14/5/3/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.32
Carlsen Magnus:   30/43/33/5/23/22/50/56/92/41/11/47/58/102/107/33/18/21/82/21/68/19/40/34/18/38/50/23/20/28/45/12/36/58/11/55/50/68/71/63/68/28/57/32/50/23/25/29/31/26/12/30/38/59/71/52/54/37/44/37/18/46/35/48/20/15/27/43/68/29/65/45/70/25/37/20/8/28/20/40/16/18/38/9/11/11/19/7/4/35/32/22/97/100/10/22/62/86/10/25/25/18/31/41/17/6/50/49/24/13/8/14/76/39/17/45/27/32/33/31/37/22/5/71/9/25/37/33/17/7/5/26/35/5/16/12/11/7/27/27/47/43/10/56/26/49/4/14/48/35/61/18/47/11/12/24/15/11/39/40/15/6/12/2/35/27/10/29/27/11/29/11/27/22/26/13/17/18/8/4/8/28/8/29/71/84/4/12/69/14/5/14/20/6/7/17/82/20/8/6/18/32/57/6/8/25/4/7/6/19/8/26/1/12/30/49/3/3/1/12/8/8/6/9/8/2/23/3/17/0  => Average=0.32
Firouzja Alireza:   55/54/29/30/38/7/9/25/48/56/33/21/13/71/86/70/54/25/35/28/28/77/47/22/23/46/46/31/26/29/48/57/68/38/35/38/35/71/76/73/54/79/29/34/37/6/58/4/101/50/29/5/56/58/49/8/7/6/39/53/52/34/35/46/40/39/65/17/22/17/21/23/9/12/9/20/20/21/80/28/26/23/22/62/15/14/30/32/37/37/41/34/36/15/27/24/27/29/7/19/19/24/34/34/57/56/53/38/41/32/54/2/16/15/28/28/16/20/21/57/59/25/28/30/15/38/25/22/13/46/11/30/16/8/44/19/20/17/9/13/13/10/14/17/40/4/14/15/65/24/1/2/10/12/67/66/10/34/37/33/10/1/11/12/13/13/4/0/0/14/4/2/2/26/23/2/0/0  => Average=0.32
So Wesley:   92/39/58/74/13/50/46/94/96/34/75/37/29/42/39/33/82/93/41/20/30/46/39/16/33/32/28/41/23/44/35/39/124/16/52/8/33/25/44/28/29/27/16/51/5/46/31/51/57/19/21/18/56/57/20/6/8/50/86/66/28/20/13/31/4/8/46/21/27/21/75/8/19/35/16/76/61/28/10/90/86/15/58/12/19/73/5/15/87/34/32/23/66/10/9/36/64/87/70/49/24/41/36/8/21/12/60/2/5/6/23/11/100/89/42/6/12/11/74/8/8/22/18/12/5/27/25/27/21/1/12/19/12/43/13/7/34/17/14/33/1/19/44/37/4/15/34/12/10/15/14/31/22/55/3/22/31/5/2/22/10/11/36/83/10/7/15/22/8/37/45/82/9/5/3/7/13/18/34/43/44/71/0/27/30/18/21/20/22/6/53/9/5/14/4/2/0/8/26/5/4/14/12/6/7/20/40/1/6/12/5/3/4/7/8/8/1/6/3/6/18/7/10/26/21/5/11/12/1/0/2/0/0/0/0/0/18/13/0/0/0  => Average=0.32
Wei Yi:   33/27/45/17/46/50/37/30/26/16  => Average=0.33
Ivanchuk Vassily:   27/57/6/51  => Average=0.33
Praggnanandhaa Rameshbabu:   60/24/35/28/84/11/4/11/57/49/56/15/29/33/75/27/23/38/7/20/23/43  => Average=0.34
Anton Guijarro David:   23/25/11/52/48/67/77/14/13/8  => Average=0.34
Aronian Levon:   64/29/40/31/14/114/68/34/30/34/6/72/42/41/36/29/38/36/151/43/76/13/21/19/21/44/53/65/62/46/24/22/27/56/62/64/52/63/39/92/82/83/85/55/51/9/47/25/53/53/115/32/61/26/38/13/82/63/58/57/55/45/70/28/43/19/64/20/99/20/19/13/41/36/42/28/11/26/30/78/19/14/23/66/62/39/61/33/20/17/71/32/32/52/26/93/29/51/39/64/26/19/38/47/27/42/57/5/34/30/30/29/30/10/52/53/30/50/9/37/31/17/44/55/21/15/9/39/17/48/19/19/22/17/2/6/7/60/42/30/30/33/39/15/28/30/27/36/44/9/47/65/29/30/9/51/30/35/33/36/46/10/15/8/7/28/33/54/47/10/27/41/1/9/19/41/42/43/17/34/15/18/30/20/4/46/15/16/42/34/23/14/0/28/12/26/16/15/63/31/10/87/52/33/84/57/23/28/26/10/18/15/31/3/1/20/13/3/19/62/12/26/43/9/37/10/22/20/8/98/55/11/16/35/6/21/20/19/76/69/4/47/18/13/9/78/99/103/12/8/30/13/25/17/20/14/15/6/6/34/37/18/2/8/77/24/20/18/12/13/21/9/25/9/23/5/11/9/5/43/15/8/4/9/13/6/8/6/0/17/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/16/10  => Average=0.36
Moussard Jules:   64/19/42/28/19  => Average=0.36
Anand Viswanathan:   56/77/20/54/61/13/25/15/10/15/5/8  => Average=0.37
Mamedyarov Shakhriyar:   67/54/127/48/46/71/48/25/28/15/38/8/10/9/75/48/51/66/17/39/67/3/92/46/25/57/44/5/11/53/25/11/35/51/4/21/25/27/51/51/63/17/5/12/15/14/13/14/11/5/28/15/16/2/5  => Average=0.37
Nakamura Hikaru:   107/90/122/27/52/66/96/28/73/78/66/26/56/56/81/26/64/52/51/48/15/33/78/70/49/36/75/30/58/18/23/25/8/61/58/44/54/36/28/5/8/19/31/96/36/3/87/55/63/53/52/36/63/94/54/43/32/25/61/41/18/64/63/40/48/15/98/14/39/22/40/14/23/17/38/5/6/39/51/46/75/39/32/29/18/50/52/80/24/86/51/50/23/87/54/4/4/5/34/31/18/45/55/19/19/39/24/10/11/21/19/43/16/27/31/51/24/70/49/29/63/84/12/81/40/56/56/21/84/57/40/60/46/75/21/41/71/34/25/17/69/62/9/58/28/15/17/6/5/52/8/18/12/21/7/7/70/26/52/44/38/62/21/14/16/68/19/13/38/41/11/25/15/41/8/39/14/15/26/13/50/22/62/31/1/95/49/28/45/54/90/27/12/19/10/17/6/7/2/30/23/8/39/2/43/31/25/72/14/61/48/21/59/20/49/51/31/38/33/30/3/12/51/25/26/10/39/50/18/37/35/16/45/25/16/32/16/11/33/38/31/15/24/14/6/0/1/22/27/35/10/28/10/15/29/9/2/9/17/16/29/42/0/7/6/39/43/67/27/37/18/6/10/45/88/10/39/36/3/16/64/31/40/31/45/17/17/81/77/3/23/51/11/20/29/5/6/110/28/9/10/11/23/36/22/9/6/35/30/13/25/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.37
Grischuk Alexander:   42/49/60/16/84/48/57/36/87/9/27/28/66/72/1/13/22/21/30/14/9/13/0/0/0  => Average=0.38
Topalov Veselin:   31/65/80/50/21/21/23/19/15/36/62/63/68/25/47/42/8/4/20  => Average=0.38
Vachier Lagrave Maxime:   35/40/96/101/12/33/50/124/9/80/68/31/88/38/10/37/10/8/18/75/16/46/13/15/0/26/52/6/28/68/42/45/46/84/10/14/15/12/38/6/23/2/42/31/3/7/6/3/0  => Average=0.38
Giri Anish:   56/37/54/38/20/63/104/31/18/66/88/41/39/94/16/67/22/10/58/52/42/33/25/71/25/47/61/19/37/3/5/7/9/72/15/7/14/37/8/9/7/19/4/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.39
Le Quang Liem:   49/45/15/14/39/53/57/75/65/20/67/29/55/40/43/48/78/17/42/51/16/15/116/52/43/22/17/8/17/72/82/14/32/58/15/32/74/6/19/15/11/53/65/17/0/0/4  => Average=0.39
Sevian Samuel:   28/85/94/64/17/49/10/41/15/29/61/68/14/32/11/8/10/93/16/21/16/18/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.40
Keymer Vincent:   56/83/47/33/37/43/70/16/35/37/13/18/44/4/43/57/34/26/37/90/16/12/8  => Average=0.40
Wang Hao:   46/84/34/5/46/4  => Average=0.40
Xiong Jeffery:   53/50/48/54/46/24/84/89/114/90/14/36/48/26/60/44/54/45/62/24/43/22/25/18/7/56/72/43/25/29/58/31/31/22/33/12/5/11/39/13/1/9/7/2/13/48/0/9/0/0  => Average=0.40
Gledura Benjamin:   21/65  => Average=0.41
Abdusattorov Nodirbek:   71/95/59/24/8/18/53/38/22/24/31/81/76/43/19/39/21/38/14/27/15/45/62/40/54/5  => Average=0.41
Niemann Hans Moke:   101/83/76/73/45/123/28/45/21/27/57/24/113/63/42/42/32/39/29/69/72/33/35/61/31/23/43/46/44/67/40/50/60/38/28/32/14/12/17/48/22/27/23/23/11/77/49/9/26/43/70/62/22/86/48/11/11/18/75/20/18/25/49/61/17/12/15/35/45/7/60/67/14/47/56/24/70/17/69/66/73/7/8/5/70/72/71/30/86/71/32/20/21/26/84/8/71/9/23/8/9/28/62/11/0/22/18/28/9/15/4/6/5/31/88/4/38/14/2/10/38/0/2/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.41
Nepomniachtchi Ian:   80/87/46/114/23/78/59/31/144/22/48/55/27/74/60/67/14/28/42/90/97/108/36/11/21/14/45/63/15/19/90/94/79/8/32/13/56/76/36/35/80/14/78/27/72/38/29/70/44/85/50/55/22/44/53/52/58/83/59/14/61/23/53/71/1/49/7/30/70/26/25/14/41/85/80/53/70/61/51/82/81/71/43/2/18/72/97/94/111/9/33/31/27/43/18/20/21/11/57/19/46/60/5/19/19/12/11/7/44/10/24/22/55/16/25/24/12/15/73/57/43/21/45/24/118/14/81/23/44/14/4/32/55/7/22/18/33/35/39/65/55/67/7/114/37/18/44/14/39/35/23/31/12/23/27/4/11/26/31/60/17/20/2/15/9/0/4/8/39/36/24/13/3/14/37/5/8/5/2/1/13/29/10/0/0/14/34/74/10/6/8/16/10/8/11/1/15/0/0/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.42
Deac Bogdan Daniel:   28/23/17/46/90/75/6/18/55/37/150/9/5  => Average=0.42
Robson Ray:   21/75/77/15/8/86/35/15  => Average=0.43
Dominguez Perez Leinier:   47/36/129/35/26/9/12/43/105/95/35/65/67/75/53/4/51/67/28/32/112/21/33/27/61/82/95/70/53/3/62/30/52/19/8/9/60/50/7/29/44/7/3/12/18/27/0/9/13/1/3  => Average=0.43
Wojtaszek Radoslaw:   44/92/45/35/18/25/71/72/6/20/7  => Average=0.43
Rapport Richard:   53/69/15/66/59/67/29/1/123/100/13/46/38/14/46/48/59/3/32/43/0/5/25/7  => Average=0.44
Erigaisi Arjun Kumar:   47/41/109/75/22/32/45/30/15/48/73/65/22/32/63/49/33/57/3/0  => Average=0.46
Duda Jan Krzysztof:   53/51/77/49/68/74/91/66/46/22/48/31/85/69/90/30/24/68/62/44/42/80/41/39/82/14/69/119/70/35/32/10/21/26/15/22/25/42/36/52/14/56/9/27/46/10/27/10/8/13/6/28/5/84/11/57/8/4/74/22/6  => Average=0.46
Dubov Daniil:   48/84/38/61/58/71/27/26/32/119/55/20/34/50/28/4/7/12/26/54/0/0  => Average=0.46
Shankland Samuel L:   22/52/49/53/51/20/20/49/56/42/92/21/37/16/69/98/96/79/32/23/9/6/108  => Average=0.46
Andreikin Dmitry:   32/58/104/25/120/72/24/81/60/20/27/61/31/93/42/38/23/14/33/58/32/8/86/45/13/19/23/80/1/3/83/33/67/1/22/31/24/0/0/0/0  => Average=0.46
Esipenko Andrey:   55/30/67/28/78/19/56/62/88/57/22/29/42/15/51/115/29/9/45/12  => Average=0.47
Kamsky Gata:   54/47/63/5/68/56/43/60/33/42  => Average=0.47
Guseinov Gadir:   46/52/0  => Average=0.47
Oparin Grigoriy:   87/71/27/29/21/50/86/40/23/5/96/16/76/35  => Average=0.48
Saric Ivan:   70/75/16/83/38/34/104/21/23/16/15/74/32/137/16/13/43/68/9/15  => Average=0.48
Maghsoodloo Parham:   85/13/61/83/43/51/73/24/61/36/55/5/37/41/0  => Average=0.49
Svidler Peter:   49  => Average=0.49
Van Foreest Jorden:   76/72/106/15/43/34/47/32/72/91/49/44/30/67/12/46/45/31/30/44/46/16/60/29/61/51/3/8  => Average=0.49
Fedoseev Vladimir1:   51/56/74/50/89/78/71/85/81/36/85/22/45/20/6/88/60/25/21/100/44/8/28/17/2/43/24/16/30/0/7/0/0/0  => Average=0.50
Eljanov Pavel:   50  => Average=0.50
Salem AR Saleh:   23/75/63/46/68/33  => Average=0.51
Harikrishna Pentala:   106/38/16/5  => Average=0.52
Jones Gawain C B:   62/84/31/31/51/87/21/68  => Average=0.55
Grandelius Nils:   25/50/107  => Average=0.55
Sunilduth Lyna Narayanan:   50/35/118/34/52/57  => Average=0.56
Matlakov Maxim:   39/77/21/46/128/79/27/74/41/60/113/80/15/47/6/78/9/0/0  => Average=0.57
Sarana Alexey:   50/69/36/94/40/49/85/60/86/42/35/69/65/102/61/76/52/72/26/60/81/36/82/20/19/13/22/17  => Average=0.58
Gelfand Boris:   43/71/72  => Average=0.60
Bluebaum Matthias:   71/50/61  => Average=0.60
Korobov Anton:   85/11/70/98/58/86  => Average=0.64
Demchenko Anton:   91/75/29/73/44/116/37/72/88/44/68/35/54  => Average=0.64
Tari Aryan:   81/147/40/65/57/15/42/8/61/175/43/18/42/35  => Average=0.65
Sjugirov Sanan:   101/134/73/88/32/29/22/77/46/45/58/34  => Average=0.67
Melkumyan Hrant:   68  => Average=0.68
Alekseenko Kirill:   69/36/111/114/40/87  => Average=0.75
Swiercz Dariusz:   125/49/31  => Average=0.78
Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 12:32 am

Here are the player scores of all games played in 2022. GM Carlsen, GM Fabiano, GM Nakamura, GM So, GM Aronian, GM Firouzja, and GM Hans Niemann in rank order.

Caruana Fabiano: => Average=0.32
Carlsen Magnus: => Average=0.32
Firouzja Alireza: => Average=0.32
So Wesley: => Average=0.32
Aronian Levon: => Average=0.36
Nakamura Hikaru: => Average=0.37
Niemann Hans Moke: => Average=0.41

Nothing seems out of sorts in the raw data. If GM Hans Niemann is cheating he is really bad at it in 2022.

Next I will post some of the detailed game data of GM Hans Niemann's lower scoring CPL games.

Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 1:46 am

[pgn][Event "Miami FTX Crypto Cup"]
[Site "Miami"]
[Date "2022.08.16"]
[Round "2.1"]
[White "Carlsen, Magnus"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B31"]
[WhiteElo "2864"]
[BlackElo "2687"]
[PlyCount "84"]
[EventDate "2022.08.15"]
[EventType "tourn (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "7"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 43"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.08.25"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.08.25"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 g6 4. O-O Bg7 5. Re1 Nf6 6. e5 Nd5 7. Nc3 Nc7 8. Bxc6 dxc6 9. Ne4 b6 10. Nf6+ Kf8 {Stockfish 270922:} 11. Ne4 Bg4 {11...h6 is the modern continuation. 11...h6 ist die moderne Fortsetzung.} 12. d3 Ne6 13. Neg5 {Inaccurate} Nxg5 {OK} 14. Bxg5 Qd5 {OK} 15. Re4 {OK} Bf5 {OK} 16. c4 {Inaccurate} Qe6 {Inaccurate} ({Predecessor:} 16... Qd7 17. Re3 Rd8 18. Qe1 h6 19. Bh4 Kg8 20. Rd1 Bg4 21. Bg3 Kh7 22. a3 Bxf3 23. Rxf3 {½-½ (63) Eid,F (2398)-Sebenik,M (2425) Beirut 2003}) 17. Re3 {OK} h6 {OK} 18. Bf4 g5 {OK} 19. Bg3 {OK} Rd8 20. h3 Kg8 {OK} 21. a3 {Inaccurate} Kh7 {OK} 22. b4 {OK} Rd7 {OK} 23. bxc5 {OK} bxc5 {Inaccurate} 24. Qb3 {OK} Rhd8 25. Rd1 {OK} Qg6 {OK} 26. Ne1 $2 {[#] Loses game (1.Cool} (26. Qa4 $15) 26... h5 $1 $19 {Strong} 27. Nf3 {OK} h4 28. Bh2 $2 {Mistake (2.6)} (28. e6) 28... e6 $19 {OK} 29. Qc3 Bf8 30. Ne1 g4 31. hxg4 {OK} Bxg4 32. f3 {Mistake (1.5)} (32. Rd2 $142) 32... Bf5 33. f4 Bh6 34. Qa5 {Mistake (1.Cool} (34. Rd2 $142) 34... Qg4 $19 {OK} 35. Rf3 (35. Qd2 $142) 35... Be4 $19 36. Qxc5 Bxf3 37. Nxf3 h3 38. Qf2 Rxd3 39. Rxd3 Rxd3 40. Ne1 Rxa3 41. Qb2 Re3 42. Kf2 Bxf4 {Strong:   Black=1 OK:   White=9, Black=11 Inaccurate:   White=3, Black=2 Mistake:   White=3 Loses game:   White=1.  Weighted Error Value: White=0.97/Black=0.12 Centipawn loss: w=83/b=16} 0-1

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "Miami FTX Crypto Cup"]
[Site "Miami"]
[Date "2022.08.20"]
[Round "6.1"]
[White "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Black "Aronian, Levon"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D78"]
[WhiteElo "2687"]
[BlackElo "2775"]
[PlyCount "81"]
[EventDate "2022.08.15"]
[EventType "tourn (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "7"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 43"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.08.25"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.08.25"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. d4 {Sumets,A} d5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. g3 g6 4. Bg2 Bg7 5. c4 c6 6. b3 O-O 7. Bb2 Bf5 {Stockfish 270922:} 8. O-O Nbd7 9. Nc3 {9.e3 is setting a new trend. 9.e3 setzt einen neuen Trend.} dxc4 10. bxc4 Nb6 {Best} 11. c5 {OK} Nc4 {OK} 12. Bc1 {Inaccurate} b6 ({Predecessor:} 12... Nd5 13. Qb3 Na5 14. Qa3 Nc4 15. Qb3 Na5 16. Qa3 Nc4 {½-½ (16) Carlsen,M (2870)-Anand,V (2775) Chennai 2013 CBM 158 [Sumets,A]}) 13. Qb3 {OK} Na5 {OK} 14. Qa3 Nd7 {Inaccurate} 15. Bf4 {OK} bxc5 {OK} 16. dxc5 Nc4 17. Qb4 {OK} Be6 18. Ng5 {Best} a5 {Best (Easy)} 19. Qb3 {OK} Nxc5 {OK} 20. Nxe6 {Best (Easy)} Nxb3 {OK} 21. Nxd8 {Best (Easy)} Nxa1 {OK} 22. Nxc6 {OK} e5 23. Bg5 {OK} Nc2 {OK} 24. Bd5 {Inaccurate} Nb6 {Mistake (1.0)} (24... h6 $11) 25. Ne7+ $16 {Best (Easy)} Kh8 26. Bxa8 {OK} Rxa8 27. Rb1 {OK} Nc4 {OK} 28. Ned5 h6 {Best} 29. Be7 {OK} Nd4 30. Rb7 {OK} Rc8 {Mistake (1.2)} (30... Nf5 $16) 31. g4 {Inaccurate} e4 {Mistake (1.3)} (31... Nc6 $142) 32. e3 $18 {OK} Nf3+ 33. Kg2 {Best (Easy)} Ncd2 {[#]} 34. Nf6 $1 {Strong} g5 {Mistake (1.4)} (34... Ne5 $142) 35. Ncxe4 $18 {OK} Nh4+ 36. Kh3 Ndf3 $2 (36... Nxe4) 37. Kg3 $18 Ng1 38. f4 Bxf6 39. Bxf6+ Kg8 40. fxg5 hxg5 41. Nxg5 {Strong:   White=1 Best:   White=5, Black=3 OK:   White=13, Black=8 Inaccurate:   White=3, Black=1 Mistake:   Black=4.  Weighted Error Value: White=0.11/Black=0.42 Centipawn loss: w=9/b=51} 1-0

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "Sinquefield Cup 9th+"]
[Site "Saint Louis"]
[Date "2022.09.04"]
[Round "3"]
[White "Carlsen, Magnus"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "E20"]
[WhiteElo "2861"]
[BlackElo "2688"]
[PlyCount "113"]
[EventDate "2022.09.02"]
[EventType "tourn"]
[EventRounds "9"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[EventCategory "21"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 46"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.09.19"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.09.19"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 Bb4 4. g3 O-O 5. Bg2 d5 6. a3 Bxc3+ 7. bxc3 dxc4 {Stockfish 270922:} 8. Nf3 c5 9. O-O cxd4 {Eine vielversprechende Nebenvariante.} 10. Qxd4 $146 ({Vorgänger:} 10. cxd4 Bd7 11. Bg5 Bc6 12. Qc2 b5 13. a4 a6 14. Rfb1 Nbd7 15. Ne5 Bxg2 16. Kxg2 Nxe5 17. dxe5 {0-1 (25) Halkias,S (2512)-Svane,R (2649) Chess.com INT 2022}) 10... Nc6 {OK} 11. Qxc4 {OK} e5 {OK} 12. Bg5 {OK} h6 13. Rfd1 {Inaccurate} Be6 {Best (Easy)} 14. Rxd8 {Best} Bxc4 {Best (Easy)} 15. Rxa8 {OK} Rxa8 16. Bxf6 {OK} gxf6 17. Kf1 {Inaccurate} Rd8 {Inaccurate} 18. Ke1 {Best} Na5 {OK} 19. Rd1 Rc8 {OK} 20. Nd2 Be6 {OK} 21. c4 {Inaccurate} Bxc4 {Inaccurate} 22. Nxc4 Rxc4 23. Rd8+ {Best} Kg7 {OK} 24. Bd5 {OK} Rc7 {OK} 25. Ra8 {Inaccurate} a6 {Best} 26. Rb8 {OK} f5 {OK} 27. Re8 {Inaccurate} e4 {OK} 28. g4 {Mistake (1.2)} (28. Rd8 $15) 28... Rc5 $19 {OK} 29. Ba2 Nc4 $2 {Missed win (1.7)} (29... fxg4 $19) 30. a4 $2 {Loses game (2.7)} (30. Bxc4 $15) 30... Nd6 $1 $19 {Strong} 31. Re7 {Mistake (1.6)} (31. Rd8 $142) 31... fxg4 {Mistake (2.0)} (31... Rc2 $142) 32. Rd7 $19 {Best} e3 {OK} 33. fxe3 {Best} Ne4 {OK} 34. Kf1 {Best} Rc1+ {Mistake (1.3)} (34... Rf5+ $19) 35. Kg2 $17 {Best} Rc2 {Best} 36. Bxf7 {Best} Rxe2+ 37. Kg1 {Best} Re1+ {OK} 38. Kg2 Re2+ {OK} 39. Kg1 {Best} Kf6 {OK} 40. Bd5 Rd2 {OK} 41. Rf7+ {Best} Kg6 {Best (Easy)} 42. Rd7 $2 (42. Re7 $17) 42... Ng5 $19 43. Bf7+ Kf5 44. Rxd2 Nf3+ 45. Kg2 Nxd2 46. a5 {[#]} Ke5 $1 47. Kg3 {[#]} Nf1+ $1 48. Kf2 Nxh2 49. e4 Kxe4 50. Be6 Kf4 51. Bc8 Nf3 52. Bxb7 Ne5 53. Bxa6 Nc6 54. Bb7 Nxa5 55. Bd5 h5 56. Bf7 h4 {Black mates} 57. Bd5 {Strong:   Black=1 Best:   White=11, Black=5 OK:   White=6, Black=16 Inaccurate:   White=5, Black=2 Mistake:   White=2, Black=2 Missed win:   Black=1 Loses game:   White=1.  Weighted Error Value: White=0.71/Black=0.20 Centipawn loss: w=63/b=17} 0-1

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "Chess.com Rapid Wk14 Swiss"]
[Site "Chess.com INT"]
[Date "2022.05.14"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Sjugirov, Sanan"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "E62"]
[WhiteElo "2696"]
[BlackElo "2656"]
[PlyCount "52"]
[EventDate "2022.05.14"]
[EventType "swiss (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "9"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 29"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.05.20"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.05.20"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. Nf3 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 Bg7 4. g3 O-O 5. Bg2 d6 6. d4 Nc6 7. O-O Bg4 8. h3 Bxf3 9. Bxf3 Nd7 10. e3 e5 {Stockfish 270922:} 11. dxe5 Ndxe5 12. Be2 Qd7 13. Kh2 {Mistake (0.Cool} (13. f4 $16) 13... Na5 $1 $11 {Strong} 14. Qd5 b6 {OK} 15. Rd1 {Inaccurate} Rad8 16. b4 {Mistake (0.9)} (16. Qe4 $15) 16... c6 $17 {OK} 17. Qe4 {OK} Nexc4 {OK} 18. Qc2 {OK} Qf5 {OK} 19. Qxf5 {OK} gxf5 20. Rd3 {Mistake (1.0)} (20. Rb1 $17) 20... Nb7 $19 {Best (Easy)} 21. Rb1 {OK} d5 {OK} 22. Kg2 b5 {Inaccurate} 23. Bf1 $2 {Mistake (1.Cool} (23. a4) 23... a5 $19 {OK} 24. Nxb5 {Mistake (2.0)} (24. Ne2 $142) 24... cxb5 $19 25. bxa5 {OK} Nc5 {Best} 26. Rd1 {OK} Ne4 {OK.  Strong:   Black=1 Best:   Black=2 OK:   White=6, Black=7 Inaccurate:   White=1, Black=1 Mistake:   White=5.  Weighted Error Value: White=0.58/Black=0.11 Centipawn loss: w=48/b=10} 0-1

[/pgn]
Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 1:55 am

[pgn][Event "Jermuk Avagyan Memorial"]
[Site "Jermuk"]
[Date "2022.06.27"]
[Round "8"]
[White "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Black "Martirosyan, Haik M"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "C54"]
[WhiteElo "2656"]
[BlackElo "2652"]
[PlyCount "119"]
[EventDate "2022.06.20"]
[EventType "tourn"]
[EventRounds "9"]
[EventCountry "ARM"]
[EventCategory "16"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 35"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.06.30"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.06.30"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bc4 Bc5 4. c3 Nf6 5. d3 d6 {Stockfish 270922:} 6. O-O h6 7. Re1 O-O 8. Nbd2 a5 9. Nf1 {OK} a4 10. Bb5 a3 {OK} 11. b4 {OK} Bb6 {OK} 12. Ng3 {Best} Ne7 {OK} 13. d4 {OK} Ng6 {Best} 14. Bd3 {OK} Bg4 {Best} 15. d5 {OK} Nh5 16. h3 $1 {Strong} Bxf3 {OK} 17. Qxf3 Nhf4 18. Nf5 Nh4 {OK} 19. Nxh4 {OK} Qxh4 20. Bf1 {Inaccurate} f5 {Mistake (1.0)} (20... Ne6 $14) 21. Bxf4 $16 {Best (Easy)} Qxf4 22. Qxf4 exf4 23. e5 {Inaccurate} dxe5 {OK} 24. Rxe5 Rae8 {Best (Easy)} 25. Rae1 Rxe5 {OK} 26. Rxe5 Rf6 {OK} 27. Bd3 g6 {OK} 28. Re8+ Rf8 $1 {Strong} 29. Re7 {Inaccurate} Rf7 {Mistake (1.2)} (29... Rd8 $11) 30. Re6 $16 {Best (Easy)} Kg7 {OK} 31. Bb5 {OK} Rf6 {OK} 32. Re7+ {OK} Rf7 {Best} 33. Re2 Rf6 {OK} 34. Ba4 g5 {Inaccurate} 35. Re7+ {Inaccurate} Rf7 {Best} 36. Re5 {OK} g4 {OK} 37. Be8 $1 {Strong} Rf6 {OK} 38. Bh5 $1 {Strong} g3 {[#] OK} 39. Kf1 $1 {Strong} c5 $2 {Mistake (3.0)} (39... Rd6) 40. fxg3 $18 {OK} cxb4 {OK} 41. cxb4 fxg3 (41... Bd8 $142) 42. Re7+ $18 Kf8 43. Rxb7 Bd4 44. Ke2 Rd6 45. Rf7+ Kg8 46. Rxf5 Rb6 47. Rf3 Be5 48. Rb3 Rb5 49. Kd3 Bd6 50. Kc4 Rb8 51. b5 Rc8+ {[#]} 52. Kd3 $1 {White is clearly winning} Kf8 53. b6 Ke7 54. b7 Rf8 55. Bg4 Rf2 56. b8=Q Bxb8 57. Rxb8 Rxg2 58. Rb6 Rb2 59. d6+ Kf7 60. d7 {Strong: White=4, Black=1 Best: White=3, Black=5 OK: White=10, Black=16 Inaccurate: White=4, Black=1 Mistake: Black=3. Weighted Error Value: White=0.07/Black=0.27 Centipawn loss: w=9/b=33} 1-0

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "FTX Road to Miami Prelim"]
[Site "chess24.com INT"]
[Date "2022.07.10"]
[Round "4"]
[White "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Black "Tari, Aryan"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D32"]
[WhiteElo "2688"]
[BlackElo "2672"]
[PlyCount "133"]
[EventDate "2022.07.10"]
[EventType "tourn"]
[EventRounds "15"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[EventCategory "19"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 38"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.07.22"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.07.22"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. Nf3 d5 2. d4 Nf6 3. c4 e6 4. Nc3 c5 5. e3 Nc6 6. cxd5 exd5 7. Bb5 cxd4 {Stockfish 270922: is recently more successful than 7...Bd6. ist inzwischen erfolgreicher als 7...Ld6.} 8. Nxd4 Bd7 9. O-O Bd6 10. Nf3 Be6 {OK} 11. b3 {OK} a6 {OK} 12. Bd3 {OK} Ne5 {OK} 13. Nxe5 {OK} Bxe5 14. Bb2 {OK} O-O {OK} 15. h3 ({Predecessor:} 15. Qd2 d4 16. exd4 Qxd4 17. Na4 Qd6 18. Bxe5 Qxe5 19. Rfe1 Qh5 {½-½ (19) Martin Sanchez,C (2510)-Bokar,J (2526) ICCF email 2020}) 15... Rc8 {OK} 16. Rc1 {OK} Qa5 {OK} 17. Qe1 {OK} Rfd8 {Mistake (1.2)} (17... Ne4 $11) 18. f4 $1 $16 {Strong} Bd6 {OK} 19. Ne4 $1 {Strong} Qxe1 {Best} 20. Nxf6+ {Best (Easy)} gxf6 21. Rfxe1 {OK} Bb4 {OK} 22. Red1 Rxc1 {OK} 23. Bxc1 Bc3 {Inaccurate} 24. g4 b5 {Inaccurate} 25. Kf2 {Inaccurate} b4 {Mistake (1.5)} (25... h5 $16) 26. Be4 $18 {OK} Rd7 {OK} 27. Bf3 {Mistake (1.1)} (27. Bb1 $18) 27... f5 $16 {Best} 28. Ke2 {Best} Kf8 $2 {Loses game (1.6)} (28... h5 $16) 29. gxf5 {Inaccurate} Bxf5 {[#]} 30. Bg4 $1 {Strong} Bxg4+ {OK} 31. hxg4 f6 $2 {Loses game (2.1)} (31... f5 $16) 32. e4 $18 {Best} Re7 {Inaccurate} 33. Rxd5 {OK} Rxe4+ {Best} 34. Be3 {Best} Re6 35. Kd3 {OK} Ke8 36. Rh5 Rd6+ {OK} 37. Ke4 {OK} Re6+ {OK} 38. Kf3 {OK} Re7 {OK} 39. Rd5 {OK} Re6 {OK} 40. Bc5 Re1 41. Rd6 {OK} a5 {[#]} 42. Ra6 $1 {Strong} f5 43. gxf5 h5 44. Rxa5 {OK} Rf1+ 45. Ke4 h4 46. Ra7 h3 47. Re7+ Kd8 48. Rh7 Rh1 49. Kd5 h2 50. Kc6 {White is clearly winning} Bd4 51. Bxd4 Rc1+ 52. Kb5 h1=Q 53. Rxh1 Rxh1 54. Kxb4 Kd7 55. a4 Kc6 56. f6 Rh8 57. Kc4 Rc8 58. Bc5 Rc7 59. b4 Rh7 60. b5+ Kd7 61. Bd4 (61. a5 $142) 61... Rh4 62. Be5 Rh1 63. a5 Rc1+ 64. Bc3 Rf1 65. Be5 Rc1+ 66. Kd5 Kc8 67. f7 {Strong: White=4 Best: White=4, Black=3 OK: White=15, Black=15 Inaccurate: White=2, Black=3 Mistake: White=1, Black=2 Loses game: Black=2. Weighted Error Value: White=0.12/Black=0.42 Centipawn loss: w=17/b=49} 1-0

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "FTX Road to Miami Prelim"]
[Site "chess24.com INT"]
[Date "2022.07.11"]
[Round "5"]
[White "Dominguez Perez, Leinier"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B12"]
[WhiteElo "2754"]
[BlackElo "2688"]
[PlyCount "70"]
[EventDate "2022.07.10"]
[EventType "tourn"]
[EventRounds "15"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[EventCategory "19"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 38"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.07.22"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.07.22"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. e4 c6 2. d4 d5 3. e5 Bf5 4. Nd2 {Stockfish 270922:} e6 5. Nb3 Ne7 6. Nf3 h6 {OK} 7. Be2 {OK} Nd7 {OK} 8. O-O g5 $1 {OK The main line 8...g5 scores better than 8...Bh7. Die Hauptvariante 8...g5 punktet besser als 8...Lh7.} 9. a4 {OK} Bg7 {OK} 10. a5 O-O {OK} 11. c3 Rc8 {Best} 12. Be3 ({Predecessor:} 12. h4 g4 13. Ne1 h5 14. f3 f6 15. fxg4 hxg4 16. exf6 Nxf6 17. Nd3 Ng6 18. Bg5 {½-½ (29) Leko,P (2693)-Ghaem Maghami,E (2574) Doha 2016}) 12... Ng6 {[#] Mistake (1.4)} (12... Be4 $14) 13. Ne1 $1 $18 {Strong} Nf4 {OK} 14. Bxf4 {OK} gxf4 15. Bd3 Qg5 {OK} 16. Nd2 f6 {OK} 17. Ndf3 {OK} Qh5 {OK} 18. Bxf5 Qxf5 19. exf6 {OK} Nxf6 20. Nd3 Ne4 {OK} 21. Nfe5 Rc7 {Mistake (0.Cool} (21... c5 $16) 22. f3 $18 {Best (Easy)} Nd6 {OK} 23. Re1 {OK} h5 {OK} 24. b4 Bxe5 {OK} 25. Rxe5 Qg6 {OK} 26. Qe2 {Mistake (1.1)} (26. a6 $16) 26... Rf6 $1 $14 {Strong} 27. Re1 {Inaccurate} Nf7 {Best (Easy)} 28. Nc5 $2 {Loses game (3.2)} (28. h3 $11) 28... Nxe5 $19 {Best (Easy)} 29. Qxe5 Rg7 {OK} 30. Qe2 {[#] OK} Qf5 {OK} 31. Rf1 $2 (31. Qd3) 31... h4 32. Rf2 h3 33. Nd3 hxg2 34. Qd1 Qh3 35. Qc1 Qxh2+ {Strong: White=1, Black=1 Best: White=1, Black=3 OK: White=7, Black=16 Inaccurate: White=1 Mistake: White=1, Black=2 Loses game: White=1. Weighted Error Value: White=0.61/Black=0.09 Centipawn loss: w=48/b=10} 0-1

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "Chess.com Rapid Wk22 Swiss"]
[Site "Chess.com INT"]
[Date "2022.07.23"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Xiong, Jeffery"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D41"]
[WhiteElo "2691"]
[BlackElo "2688"]
[PlyCount "84"]
[EventDate "2022.07.23"]
[EventType "swiss (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "9"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 39"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.07.29"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.07.29"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nf3 d5 4. Nc3 c5 5. cxd5 {Stockfish 270922:} cxd4 6. Qxd4 exd5 7. e4 dxe4 $1 {OK is currently scoring better than 7...Nc6. wohl besser als 7...Sc6.} 8. Qxd8+ {OK} Kxd8 9. Ng5 {OK} Be6 {OK} 10. g3 Bb4 {OK} 11. Bd2 {OK} Ke7 {OK} 12. Nxe6 ({Predecessor:} 12. Bg2 Nc6 13. Nxe6 Kxe6 14. Nxe4 Nxe4 15. Bxe4 Bxd2+ 16. Kxd2 Rad8+ 17. Ke3 Ne5 18. Rac1 {½-½ (42) Nepomniachtchi,I (2789)-So,W (2770) chess24.com INT 2021}) 12... fxe6 13. Bg2 {OK} Nc6 {OK} 14. a3 Bxc3 {OK} 15. Bxc3 Rhd8 {OK} 16. O-O {OK} Nd4 {Best} 17. Rae1 {OK} Nf3+ {OK} 18. Bxf3 {Best (Easy)} exf3 19. Bb4+ Kd7 {OK} 20. Re3 {OK} Nd5 {Best} 21. Rd1 {OK} a5 {OK} 22. Bc3 Ke7 {OK} 23. Rxf3 {OK} Nxc3 {OK} 24. Rxd8 {OK} Rxd8 25. Rxc3 {Best (Easy)} Rd1+ 26. Kg2 Kd7 27. Rf3 Kc6 {OK} 28. Rf7 Rd7 {Best (Easy)} 29. Rxd7 Kxd7 30. Kf3 {OK} e5 {OK} 31. Ke4 Kd6 32. b3 b5 {OK} 33. f4 exf4 {OK} 34. gxf4 Kc5 {OK} 35. f5 a4 {OK} 36. bxa4 {OK} bxa4 37. Ke5 {OK} h5 {OK} 38. h4 Kc4 {Best (Easy)} 39. Ke6 {OK} Kd4 {OK} 40. Kf7 Ke5 {OK} 41. Kg6 {OK} Kf4 {Inaccurate} 42. Kxh5 {OK} Kxf5 {Best (Easy). Best: White=2, Black=5 OK: White=16, Black=21 Inaccurate: Black=1. Weighted Error Value: White=0.02/Black=0.00 Centipawn loss: w=2/b=1} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]
Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 2:03 am

[pgn][Event "Chess.com Rapid Wk24 Swiss"]
[Site "Chess.com INT"]
[Date "2022.08.06"]
[Round "6"]
[White "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Black "Xiong, Jeffery"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "C42"]
[WhiteElo "2687"]
[BlackElo "2690"]
[PlyCount "29"]
[EventDate "2022.08.06"]
[EventType "swiss (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "9"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 42"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.08.20"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.08.20"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. Nxe5 d6 4. Nd3 {Stockfish 270922:} (4. Nf3 $16) 4... Nxe4 $11 5. Qe2 Qe7 6. Nf4 Nc6 {OK} 7. Nd5 {OK} Nd4 {OK} 8. Nxe7 {OK} Nxe2 {OK} 9. Nd5 {OK} Nd4 {OK} 10. d3 {Inaccurate} Nxc2+ {Best} 11. Kd1 {Best (Easy)} Nxa1 {Best (Easy)} 12. dxe4 {OK} Kd8 {OK} 13. Bg5+ {OK} f6 {Best (Easy)} 14. Be3 {OK} c6 {Best (Easy)} 15. Nf4 {Best (Easy). Best: White=2, Black=4 OK: White=6, Black=5 Inaccurate: White=1. Weighted Error Value: White=0.10/Black=0.00 Centipawn loss: w=9/b=1} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]

[pgn][Event "Chess.com Rapid Wk24 KO"]
[Site "Chess.com INT"]
[Date "2022.08.07"]
[Round "2.2"]
[White "Nakamura, Hikaru"]
[Black "Niemann, Hans Moke"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D32"]
[WhiteElo "2768"]
[BlackElo "2687"]
[PlyCount "50"]
[EventDate "2022.08.07"]
[EventType "k.o. (rapid)"]
[EventRounds "3"]
[EventCountry "USA"]
[SourceTitle "Mega2022 Update 42"]
[Source "Chessbase"]
[SourceDate "2022.08.20"]
[SourceVersion "1"]
[SourceVersionDate "2022.08.20"]
[SourceQuality "1"]

1. Nf3 d5 2. e3 Nf6 3. c4 e6 4. Nc3 c5 5. cxd5 exd5 6. d4 Nc6 7. Bb5 cxd4 $1 {Stockfish 270922: is recently more successful than 7...Bd6. ist inzwischen erfolgreicher als 7...Ld6.} 8. Nxd4 Bd7 9. O-O Bd6 10. Nf3 a6 11. Be2 {Inaccurate} Be6 {OK} 12. b3 {OK} O-O {OK} 13. Bb2 {Best} Qe7 {OK} 14. Rc1 Rad8 15. Nd4 {Inaccurate} Bd7 {Inaccurate} 16. Nxc6 {OK} Bxc6 $146 ({Predecessor:} 16... bxc6 17. Bf3 h5 18. g3 h4 19. Ne2 Rfe8 20. Nf4 hxg3 21. hxg3 Be5 22. Qc2 Ne4 23. Bxe4 dxe4 24. Bxe5 Qxe5 {0-1 (38) De Jager,J (2437)-Lai,H (2455) Amstelveen 2019}) 17. Nb1 {OK} Be5 18. Ba3 {Inaccurate} Bd6 19. Bxd6 Rxd6 20. Qd4 {OK} Ne4 {OK} 21. Nc3 {OK} Ng5 {OK} 22. Rfd1 {OK} Ne6 {OK} 23. Qb4 $2 {[#] Loses game (4.2)} (23. Qe5 $11) 23... d4 $1 $19 {Strong} 24. exd4 Nxd4 25. Bg4 (25. Rxd4 $142) 25... Nf3+ {Strong: Black=1 Best: White=1 OK: White=6, Black=6 Inaccurate: White=3, Black=1 Loses game: White=1. Weighted Error Value: White=0.77/Black=0.04 Centipawn loss: w=53/b=5} 0-1

[/pgn]

Back to top Go down
mwyoung

mwyoung


Posts : 880
Join date : 2020-11-25
Location : USA

Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. EmptyWed Oct 05, 2022 2:04 am

Does anyone see any cheating from the games or raw data?
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.   Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess. Empty

Back to top Go down
 
Lets have fun and look for real cheaters in chess.
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» Play online chess with real chess board
» The Year Computer Chess Overtook The Very Best Human Chess Play.
» Live Chess 960 Match Dragon by Komodo Chess vs Stockfish 291120 (TC=90m+30s)(32 Threads)
» How strong can the smartest chess engine in the world play intuitive chess?
» Computer Chess Engine Classical Chess Championship. Stockfish 14 vs. Dragon 2.5.1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
ProDeo :: Computer Chess-
Jump to: